Cooking Cape Cod Fish: A Simple Approach

When I find myself standing in the kitchen with a beautiful piece of fresh fish, the first thing I do is pause and appreciate what I’m holding. Years on Cape Cod have taught me that cooking fish isn’t complicated. It’s a matter of respecting the catch and keeping the preparation straightforward and honest.

Start With Fish That Truly Tells Its Story

At Chatham Harvesters, our fishermen bring in seafood that almost writes its own recipe. When the fish is fresh, my guiding principle is simple: Thaw it carefully in the refrigerator overnight and don’t overwork it.

Before I think about heat or seasoning, I make sure the fish comes from people who can tell

me its story: where it was caught, who caught it, and what vessel brought it to shore. That connection to the working waterfront is central to how we approach seafood on Cape Cod. Cooking begins with understanding the journey of the fish itself.

Keep the Preparation Simple

My cooking philosophy comes down to four ingredients: butter, lemon, herbs, heat. These elements enhance the natural flavor without competing with it.

Here’s how I prepare a basic fish dish:

Pat the fish dry.

Season lightly with salt and pepper.

Add a small pat of butter.

Squeeze just enough lemon to brighten the flavor.

Add parsley, tarragon or thyme if you want a subtle herbal note.

Bake or pan-sear until the fish flakes easily.

There’s no need for heavy sauces or elaborate marinades. Cook until the internal temperature reaches 145°F, or rely on the visual cue of gentle flaking. Simplicity allows the quality of the fish to shine.

Don’t Overthink Doneness

As I often say: “With fish, doneness isn’t guesswork. Your eyes and fork will tell you when it’s ready.”

Fish cooks quickly, and that can make people nervous—but it shouldn’t. If it flakes easily with a fork, it’s ready. If it’s still translucent in the center, it needs a moment more. I tend to remove it from the heat slightly early; residual heat finishes the job while I ready the rest of the meal.

Make Friends With the One-Pan Meal

Efficiency matters in my kitchen. If I can cook a dish in one pan, I will. It keeps things simple and allows me to focus on ingredients rather than cleanup.

A favorite approach is layering seasonal vegetables—cherry tomatoes, asparagus, summer squash—on a sheet pan, tossing them in olive oil, placing the fish on top, seasoning, and roasting. By the time I’ve poured a glass of wine or set the table, dinner is ready.

Honor the Story Behind the Seafood

For me, Cape Cod seafood carries more than flavor. It holds heritage, history, and the strength of a community shaped by the working waterfront. I think about the families, the boats, and the longstanding tradition of sustainable harvesting each time I prepare a meal.

Cooking local fish is a way of participating in that ongoing story—a reminder that food can connect us to place, people, and the environment that sustains us.

My Five-Minute Fisherman’s Broil

When time is short, this is the dish I rely on.

Ingredients:

White fish such as haddock, halibut, or sea bass, even mackerel or bluefish

Mayonnaise

Crushed Ritz crackers or panko

Paprika

Lemon

Directions:

Spread a thin layer of mayonnaise over the fish.

Press in the cracker crumbs to form a light crust.

Sprinkle paprika for color and warmth.

Broil until the top is golden and the fish flakes easily.

It’s fast, reliable, and consistently flavorful, and perfect for busy evenings.

Let the Fish Shine

Cooking fish should feel natural and unforced, much like life near the Atlantic. When the ingredients are handled with care, there’s no need to complicate the process. Respect the fish, keep the method simple, and let the flavors speak for themselves.

********************************************************************************************

Shareen Davis:

Shareen Davis is the Marketing and Sales Manager and creates the recipe blog for Chatham Harvesters Cooperative. A true seafood enthusiast with deep, generational roots in Chatham’s fishing community, she blends her love of local flavors with her passion for sharing the stories behind the catch.